The Politics of Pure Experience

Individual and State in An Inquiry into the Good

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.4312/as.2023.11.3.177-202

Keywords:

Nishida Kitarō, pure experience, Miyake Setsurei, Nitobe Inazō, Meiji Period, nationalism, imperialism, self-realization

Abstract

In this contribution, I shall attempt to clearly work out the political implications of Nishida Kitaro’s theory of pure experience in An Inquiry into the Good. This effort comes in response to the multitude of vastly different claims about the political meaning and dangers of Nishida’s early philosophy. Is it an implicit foundation for Japanese nationalism and the seeds of the controversial political philosophy he would work out later? Or is it a subtle attempt to critique the nationalist philosophy and educational policies surrounding Nishida while he was writing in the Meiji era? Or, perhaps most obviously, is this work unconnected with any and all political matters (including those that Nishida would face later on in his life)? In this paper, I shall argue that, although there is good reason to endorse any of these claims, ultimately a balanced assessment will find that Nishida’s early philosophy was indeed apolitical in nature, and that attempts to claim the contrary inevitably either go beyond textual evidence or miss key elements of his thought. Yet, as I shall further argue, being apolitical hardly means that Nishida’s work has no political consequences. Instead, for better or worse, the defining characteristic of Nishida’s early political philosophy is its capacity to allow readers to transcend such political issues.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Arisaka, Yoko. 1996. “The Nishida Enigma: The Principle of the New World Order.” Monumenta Nipponica 51 (1): 81‒105. https://doi.org/10.2307/2385317. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2385317

Berlin, Isaiah. [1958] 2017. “Two Concepts of Liberty.” In Liberty, edited by Henry Hardy, 166–217. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/019924989X.003.0004

Fujita, Masakatsu 藤田正勝. 2022. Nishida Kitarō Zen no Kenkyū wo Yomu 西田幾多郎「善の研究」を読む (Reading Nishida Kitaro’s An Inquiry into the Good). Tokyo: Chikuma Shinsho.

Funayama, Shinichi 船山信一. [1959] 1965. Meiji Tetsugakushi Kenkyū 明治哲学史研究 (Research on Meiji Philosophy). Kyoto: Minerva Shobo.

———. [1959] 1998. “Nihon no Kannenronja 日本の観念論者 (Japan’s Idealists).” In Funayama Shinichi Zenshu Dai 8 Kan 船山信一全集第8巻 (Complete Works of Funayama Shinichi, vol. 8), edited by Fukabe et al., 9‒267. Tokyo: Kobushi Kobo.

Gluck, Carol. 1985. Japan’s Modern Myths: Ideology in the Late Meiji Period. Princeton: Princeton Paperbacks. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9780691232676

Goto-Jones, Christopher S. 2005. Political Philosophy in Japan: Nishida, the Kyoto-School and Co-Prosperity. New York: Routledge.

Hirai, Atsuko. 1979. “Self-Realization and Common Good: T. H. Green in Meiji Ethical Thought.” The Journal of Japanese Studies 5: 107–136. https://doi.org/10.2307/132088. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/132088

———. 1988. “Anglo-American Influences on Nishida Kitarō.” In Japan and the World, edited by G. L. Bernstein, and H. Fukui, 20‒41. London: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-08682-5_2

Howland, Douglas. R. 2001. Translating the West. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.

Inoue, Katsuhito. 2016. “The Philosophical World of Meiji Japan.” Translated by Takeshi Morisato. European Journal of Japanese Philosophy 1: 10‒30. https://ejjpenojp.files.wordpress.com/2021/05/ejjp-1-1-inoue.pdf.

Itabashi, Yujin. 2014. “No Effort, Just Peace: Peace and Its Ground-Less-Ness in Nishida’s Philosophy.” Poligrafi 19 (75/76): 27‒40. http://ojs.zrs-kp.si/index.php/poligrafi/issue/view/26. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10402659.2014.876304

Knauth, Lothar. 1965. “Life is Tragic: The Diary of Nishida Kitaro.” Monumenta Nipponica 20 (3/4): 335‒58. https://doi.org/10.2307/2383330. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2383330

Kurata, Hyakuzo. [1912] 2020. “Looking for One’s Self in the Opposite Sex.” Translated by Richard Stone. Asian Philosophical Texts, vol. 1, edited by Takeshi Morisato, and Roman Pasca, 259‒80. Milan: Mimesis International.

Kweon, Seok Yeong 権 錫永. 2008. “Nitobe Inazō no Chosen Bokokuron 新渡戸稲造の朝鮮亡国論 (Nitobe Inazō’s Theory of Korea as a Perished Country).” Bulletin of the Faculty of Humanities and Human Sciences 126: 37‒60.

———. 2021. “Shishō Kadai to shite no Teikokushugi: ‘Dōtoku no Shinpo’ wo Meguru Giron wo Tegakari ni 思想課題としての帝国主義-「道徳の進歩」をめぐる議論を手がかりに― (Imperialism as a Thought Process: Taking Debates on ‘Moral Progress’ as a Guide).” Tetsugaku Nenpo (Hokkaido Tetsugakkai) 67: 41‒77.

Lavelle, Pierre. 1994. “The Political Thought of Nishida Kitarō.” Monumenta Nipponica 49 (2): 139‒65. https://doi.org/10.2307/2385167. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2385167

Miki, Kiyoshi 三木清. [1941] 1967. “Nishida Sensei no Kotodomo 西田先生のことども (About Professor Nishida).” In Miki Kiyoshi Zenshu Dai 10 Kan 三木清全集第10巻 (Complete Works of Miki Kiyoshi, vol. 10). Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.

Miyajima, Hajime 宮島肇. 1960. Meijiteki Shisōkazō no Keisei – Nishida Tetsugaku Seiritsushi to Shisōshi Hōhōron no Mondai 明治的思想家像の形成―西田哲学成立史と思想史方法論の問題― (The Forming of the Image of Meiji Thinker: On the Establishment of Nishida Philosophy and the Problem of Methodology in Intellectual History). Tokyo: Miraisha.

Miyakawa, Toru. 宮川徹. 1962. Kindai Nihon no Tetsugaku 近代日本の哲学 (Japan’s Modern Philosophy). Tokyo: Keiso Shobo.

Miyake, Setsurei 三宅雪嶺. [1891] 1931. “Shinzenbi Nihonjin 真善美日本人 (The Good, True, and Beautiful of the Japanese People).” In Gendai Bungaku Zenshu Dai 5 Hen: Miyake Setsurei Shu 現代文学全集第5編・三宅雪嶺集 (Works of Modern Japanese Literature Miyake Setsurei, vol. 5). Tokyo: Kaizosha.

———. [1892] 1967. Miyake Setsurei Shu 三宅雪嶺集 (Miyake Setsurei Collection). Edited by Yanagita Izumi. Meiji Bungakushū, vol. 33. Tokyo: Chikuma Shobo.

———. 1909. Uchu 宇宙 (The Cosmos). Tokyo: Seikyosha.

Morita, Yasuo 森田康夫. 2015. [Hyōden] Miyake Setsurei no Shisōzō [評伝]三宅雪嶺の思想像 (An Image of Miyake Setsurei’s Thought). Tokyo: Izumi Sensho.

Nagatsuma, Misao 長妻三佐雄. 2012. Miyake Setsurei no Shisōshi: “Shinzenbi” no Yukue 三宅雪嶺の政治思想: 「真善美」の行方 (Miyake Setsurei’s Political Thought: In Search of The True, The Good, and The Beautiful). Kyoto: Minerva.

Nishida, Kitarō 西田幾多郎. 1965. “Takahashi (Satomi) Bungakushi no Seccho Zen no Kenkyū ni Taisuru Hihan ni Kotau 高橋(里美)文学士の拙著『善の研究』に対する批判に答ふ (Responding to Mr. Takahashi Satomi’s Criticism of my Work, An Inquiry into the Good).” In Nishida Kitarō Zenshu Dai 1 Kan 西田幾多郎全集第1巻 (Complete Works of Nishida Kitarō, vol. 1). Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.

———. 1966. “Junsui Keiken ni Kansuru Dansho 純粋経験に関する断書 (Writings on Pure Experience).” In Nishida Kitarō Zenshu Dai 16 Kan 西田幾多郎全集第16巻 (Complete Works of Nishida Kitarō, vol. 16). Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.

———. [1911] 1990. An Inquiry Into the Good. Translated by Masao Abe and Christopher Ives. New Haven, London: Yale University Press.

Nishitani, Keiji. 1991. Nishida Kitarō. Translated by Yamamoto Seisaku and James W. Heisig. Berkeley, Los Angeles: University of California Press.

Nolte, Sharon H. 1983. “National Morality and Universal Ethics. Ōnishi Hajime and the Imperial Rescript on Education.” Monumenta Nipponica 38 (3): 283‒94. https://doi.org/10.2307/2384883. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2384883

Osaki, Harumi. 2019. Nothingness in the Heart of Empire: The Moral and Political Philosophy of the Kyoto School in Imperial Japan. Albany: SUNY Press.

Parkes, Graham. 1997. “The Putative Fascism of the Kyoto School and the Political Correctness of the Modern Academy.” Philosophy East and West 47 (3): 305‒36. https://doi.org/10.2307/1399908. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1399908

Reitan, Richard. M. 2009. Making a Moral Society: Ethics and the State in Meiji Japan. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.21313/hawaii/9780824832940.001.0001

Stone, Richard. 2018. “Independence and Self-Realization: The Historical Background of the Early Nishida’s Individualism.” European Journal of Japanese Philosophy 3: 31‒56. https://ejjpenojp.files.wordpress.com/2021/05/ejjp-3-2-stone.pdf.

———. 2022. “Nishida Kitarō’s Two True Selves: Revisiting Self, Meaning, and Method in An Inquiry Into The Good.” Journal of Japanese Philosophy 8: 47‒71. https://doi.org/10.1353/jjp.2022.0006. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/jjp.2022.0006

Wargo, Robert. J. J. 1972. “The Logic of Basho and the Concept of Nothingness in the Philosophy of Nishida Kitaro.” PhD diss., University of Michigan.

———. 2005. The Logic of Nothingness: A Study of Nishida Kitaro. Honolulu; University of Hawaii Press.

Yusa, Michiko. 2002. Zen and Philosophy: An Intellectual Biography of Nishida Kitarō. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.

Downloads

Published

7. 09. 2023

How to Cite

Stone, Richard. 2023. “The Politics of Pure Experience: Individual and State in An Inquiry into the Good”. Asian Studies 11 (3): 177-202. https://doi.org/10.4312/as.2023.11.3.177-202.

Similar Articles

1-10 of 95

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.