Uncovering the Provenance of “Orphaned” Objects

An Experimental Provenance Case Study on Scattered Pages of the Huangchao Liqi Tushi Qing Imperial Album in Western Collections

Authors

  • ZHAO Haoyang University of Glasgow, United Kingdom

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.4312/as.2025.13.1.289-322

Keywords:

Huangchao liqi tushi 皇朝禮器圖式, provenance research, history of collecting, looted objects, Yuanmingyuan 圓明園

Abstract

In recent years, scattered pages of the coloured version of Huangchao liqi tushi have been found in several public institutions outside China and even on the art market. The discovery of pages bearing the Yuanmingyuan seal has led to them being associated with the looting of Yuanmingyuan in 1860. However, as commonly encountered in provenance research, a thorough analysis of the available archives indicates that portions of pages held in various institutions were acquired from unrelated individuals or dealers at different times, without substantial evidence linking them directly to the looting of Yuanmingyuan or to soldiers involved in the looting. Consequently, it is not possible to definitively establish their Yuanmingyuan provenance. Facing these challenges, this study employs methods beyond the traditional archival research approach, demonstrating how additional insights can be derived from checking indirect archives and marks on the reverse of pages. More importantly, the study showcases how an art historical understanding of the material can offer new perspectives, shifting the focus from searching for provenance documents of individual portions to connecting portions without records to those with more solid evidence, considering the possibility that direct provenance records may never have existed.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

References

British Museum. n.d. “Edwin Parsons & Sons.” Accessed March 3, 2024. www.britishmuseum.org/collection/term/BIOG26077.

Collins, Bruce. 2021. “Punitive Expeditions in China, 1857–1860.” In Queen Victoria’s Wars British Military Campaigns, 1857–1902, edited by Stephen M. Miller, 40‒60. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Davids, Roy, and Dominic Jellinek. 2011. Provenance: Collectors, Dealers and Scholars in the Field of Chinese Ceramics in Britain and America. Oxford: Privately Printed by Roy Davids.

Dickinson, Gray, and Linda Wrigglesworth. 1990. Imperial Wardrobe. London: Bamboo Publishing.

FeteChinoise. 2022. “Flower Numbers 花碼字: A Chinese Counting Legacy 中國數字之小歷史.” FeteChinoise, October 7, 2022. Accessed August 2, 2024. www.fetechinoise.ca/blog/2022/flower-numbers.

Hevia, James L. 2003. English Lessons: The Pedagogy of Imperialism in Nineteenth-century China. Durham: Duke University Press.

Hevia, James L. 2018. “The Afterlives of a Ruin.” In Collecting and Displaying China’s ‘Summer Palace’ in the West: The Yuanmingyuan in Britain and France, edited by Luise Tythacott, 25‒37. Oxford: Routledge.

Hill, Kate. 2018. “The Yuanmingyuan and Design Reform in Britain.” In Collecting and Displaying China’s ‘Summer Palace’ in the West: The Yuanmingyuan in Britain and France, edited by Luise Tythacott, 53‒71. New York: Routledge.

Hobson, Rev. J. P. 1896. “China.” In A Primer of Modern Missions, edited by Richard Lovett, M. A., 107–35. London: The Religious Tract Society. www.google.co.uk/books/edition/A_Primer_of_Modern_Missions/dOtEAAAAYAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1.

Irving, Miles, and George William De Rhé-Philipe. 1989. Soldier of the Raj. London: London Stamp Exchange.

Ji, Xianlin 季羨林, and Xu Juan 徐娟, eds. 1997. “Neiwubu Guwu Chenliesuo Shuhua Mulu 內務部古物陳列所書畫目錄 (List of Paintings and Writings/Texts/Calligraphies Held in the Neiwubu Institution of Antiques).” In Zhongguo Lidai Shuhua Yishu Lunzhu Conbian 中國歷代書畫藝術論著叢編 (Collected Essays on the Art of Chinese Calligraphy and Painting through the Ages), vol. 13, 543–54. Beijing: Zhongguo da bai ke quan shu chu ban she.

Knollys, Henry. 1885. English Life in China. London: Smith Elder & Son.

Lai, Yu-chih 賴毓芝. 2020. “Tu yu li. Huangchao Liqi Tushi; de chengli yu qi yingxiang 「圖」與禮《皇朝禮器圖式》的成立及其影響 (‘Illustrations’ and the Rites: The Formation of Illustrated Regulations for Ceremonial Paraphernalia of the Imperial Qing Dynasty and Its Influence).” National Palace Museum Research Quarterly 37 (2): 4.

Macmunn, George. 1936. History of the Sikh Pioneers: 23rd, 32nd, 34th. London: Sampson Low, Marston & Co., Ltd.

Mak, George Kam Wah. 2017. Protestant Bible Translation and Mandarin as the National Language of China. Leiden: Brill.

Medley, Margret. 1957-1959. “The Illustrated Regulations for Ceremonial Paraphernalia of the Ch’ing Dynasty in the Victoria and Albert Museum.” Transactions of the Oriental Ceramic Society 59: 95–105.

Qinding Shiqu Baoji Xubian 钦定石渠宝笈续编. n.d. Vol. 18. www.archive.org/details/02094582.cn/page/n35/mode/2up?view=theater.

Qinggong neiwufu zaobanchu dangan zonghui 清宮內務府造辦處總匯 (Zaobanchu Archives of the Qing Imperial Household Department). 2005. vol. 40. Beijing: Renmin chubanshe.

Stock, Eugene. 1899. The History of the Church Missionary Society, Its Environment, Its Men and Its Work. London: Church Missionary Society. https://archive.org/details/historychurchmis02stoc/page/306/mode/2up.

Temple, William. 1894. The Thanage of Fermartyn. Aberdeen: D. Wyllie & Son. www.archive.org/details/thanageoffermart00temp/page/44/mode/2up.

The Connoisseur. 1951. “W. Wheeler & Son Ltd.” The Connoisseur, January 1951, plate. VIII. www.archive.org/details/connoisseurill126128lond/page/n303/mode/2up?q=Wheeler.

Vollmer, John E., and Jacqueline Simcox. 2009. Emblems of Empire: Selections from the Mactaggart Art Collection. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.

Wang, Chunfa 王春法. 2021. Zhongguo gudai fushi wenhua 中國古代服飾文化 (Ancient Chinese Cultures: Costume and Adornment). Beijing: Beijing shidai wenhua shuju.

Welch, Ian Hamilton. 2013. The Protestant Episcopal Church of the United States of America, in China and Japan, 1835–1870. Australian National University. www.openresearch-repository.anu.edu.au/items/cfd50baf-b1e8-4493-bb71-6c5bb6b64c56.

Whitty, Audrey. 2022. “A History of Collecting of Asian Material Culture by the National Museum of Ireland, with a particular focus on the Albert Bender Collection.” Oriental Ceramic Society Lecture Series. May 10, 2022. www.orientalceramicsociety.org.uk/events/a-history-of-collecting-of-asian-material-culture-by-the-national-museum-of-ireland-with-a-particular-focus-on-the-albert-bender-collection.

Who Was Who, 1916-1928: A Companion to Who’s Who, Containing the Biographies of Those Who Died during the Period 1916‒1928. 1967. “Upperton, Maj. – Gen. John, CB.” London: Adam & Charles Black.

Wilson, Ming. 2003-2004. “New Research on the Ceremonial Paraphernalia Album in the V&A.” Transactions of the Oriental Ceramic Society 68: 51‒59.

Zhao, Haoyang. 2019. “Objects of Multiple Meanings, a Provenance Research of the Huangchao Liqi Tushi (Illustrations of Imperial Ritual Paraphernalia) Circulated and Collected in the British Isles in the Mid–late 19th Century.” MA thesis, University of Glasgow.

Zhao, Haoyang. 2020. “Art Historical and Provenance Research in a Case Study of Huangchao Liqi Tushi.” Journal for Art Market Studies 4 (2): 6‒11. doi.org/10.23690/jams.v4i2.128.

*****

Auction Records

Bainbridges. 2017. “Antiques, Collectables and General Effects.” May 25, 2017, lot 615. Accessed October 27, 2023. www.the-saleroom.com/en-us/auction-catalogues/a-bainbridge-and-co/catalogue-id-srba10035/lot-1f70e68b-98f1-4983-b0af-a7790149a5f5.

Bonhams San Francisco. 2006. “Fine Asian Works of Art.” November 20, 2006, lot 6172. Accessed October 22, 2023. www.bonhams.com/auctions/14043/lot/6172/?category=list&length=385&page=1.

Christie’s Hong Kong. 2006. “The Imperial Sale.” May 30, 2006, lot 1302. Accessed October 22, 2023. www.christies.com/lot/lot-a-set-of-four-album-leaves-from-4721956/?lid=1&sc_lang=en.

Christie’s Paris. 2017. “Art d’Asie.” December 13, 2017, lot 108. Accessed October 22, 2023. www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-6117950.

Dix Noonan Webb Auctions. 2004. “The Brian Ritchie Collection of H.E.I.C. and British India Medals, Part 1.” September 17, 2004, lot 92. www.archive.org/details/auctionofbrianri00dixn/page/91/mode/2up?q=upperton.

Dix Noonan Webb ltd. 2020. “An Auction of Orders, Decorations, Medals and Militaria.” November 12, 2020, lot 491. www.content.yudu.com/libraryHtml/A441yj/Medals12Nov20/151.html?page=150&origin=reader.

Puttick & Simpsons. 1854. “The Macartney Sale.” January 24, 1854.

Puttick & Simpsons. 1863. February 4, 1863, lot 173.

Sotheby’s London. 1988. “The Library of Philip Robinson Part II, The Chinese Collection’ Sale.” November 22, 1988.

Sotheby Parke Bernet Inc, New York. 1984. “Fine Chinese Works of Art, Paintings and Furniture Including China Trade Paintings, Chinese Export and Decorative Arts.” March 17, 1984, lot 81.

Wooley & Wallis. 2019. “Fine Chinese Paintings & Works of Art.” November 12, 2019, lot 6.

*****

Museum Archives

British Library Archives. Reference Dh46, In-Letters of the Department of Oriental Manuscripts and Printed Books ‘Up to 1950’ (box K-L).

British Library Archives. The Official Correspondence records for the Department of Oriental Printed Books and Manuscripts related to Or. 9430 and Or. 9431.

British Library Archives. Reference: Dh40, Department of Oriental Manuscripts and Printed Books: Register of Oriental Manuscripts (Or 9035-12220, 1922–1958).

British Library Archives. Reference: Dh36/4, Department of Oriental Manuscripts and Printed Books: Register of Donations, 1921–26.

The National Archives of the UK (TNA). The 1891 England Census, “Hobson, John Philip”; Kew, Surrey, England; Census Returns of England and Wales, 1891; Class: RG12; Piece: 146; Folio: 144; Page: 16; GSU roll: 6095256. www.ancestry.co.uk/discoveryui-content/view/7909770:6598?tid=&pid=&queryId=5047ebb0f291b2b226633a2ed1e5e215&_phsrc=bXQ18&_phstart=successSource.

V&A Archive. “Harris, W. H.” MA/1/H848.

V&A Archive. “Hobson, the Revd. J.P.” MA/1/H2254.

V&A Archive. “W. Wheeler & Son.” MA/1/W1470.

V&A Archive. 1990. Central Inventory Manuscript List. “D.1946 to 2017-1900.” MA/30/207.

V&A Archive. 1953. Central Inventory Manuscript List. “E.1706 to 1833-1953.” MA/30/298.

*****

Newspaper Archives

Aberdeen Press and Journal. 1873. “The Opening of the Arts Exhibition.” Aberdeen Press and Journal, August 6, 1873: 5. www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk/viewer/BL/0000031/18730806/016/0005.

Aberdeen Press and Journal. 1886. “Aberdeen—Winter Exhibition in Art Gallery.” Aberdeen Press and Journal, January 18, 1886: 4. www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk/viewer/bl/0000575/18860118/080/0004.

Hart’s Annual Army List, Special Reserve List, and Territorial Force List. 1880. “Bengal Staff Corps – War Services,” vol. 41, note 477. www.google.co.uk/books/edition/Hart_s_Annual_Army_List_Special_Reserve/UzgwAQAAMAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=J.+Upperton+1860&pg=PA470&printsec=frontcover.

Downloads

Published

15. 01. 2025

How to Cite

Zhao, Haoyang. 2025. “Uncovering the Provenance of ‘Orphaned’ Objects: An Experimental Provenance Case Study on Scattered Pages of the Huangchao Liqi Tushi Qing Imperial Album in Western Collections”. Asian Studies 13 (1): 289-322. https://doi.org/10.4312/as.2025.13.1.289-322.